Let’s stop stigma – support better mental health

Religion boosts mental health, research says

Religious people have better mental health than non-believers, new research has revealed.

Those who follow a faith, regardless of which one, have enhanced well-being, which scientists attribute to their spirituality. 

And doctors could take advantage of this relationship by tailoring treatments and rehabilitation programs that accommodate a patient's religious beliefs - especially among mental health sufferers.

Professor Dan Cohen, of the University of Missouri in the United States, said: 'Our prior research shows that the mental health of people recovering from different medical conditions, such as cancer, stroke, spinal cord injury and traumatic brain injury, appears to be related significantly to positive spiritual beliefs and especially congregational support and spiritual interventions.'

He said that those who seek spirituality may help them come to terms with mentally challenging situations, like stress or neuroticism

He said: 'Spiritual beliefs may be a coping device to help individuals deal emotionally with stress.'

The researchers used three surveys to determine if correlations exist among people's mental and physical health, personality factors, and spirituality in Buddhists, Muslims, Jews, Catholics and Protestants.

Across all five faiths, results showed a higher level of spirituality was related to better mental health, particularly lower levels of neuroticism and greater extraversion despite how often the patients participated in religious activities.

The researchers believe spirituality may help people's mental health by reducing how self-centred they are and developing their sense of belonging to a larger whole.

Spiritual interventions - such as religious-based counselling, meditation, and forgiveness protocols - could enhance spiritually-based beliefs, practices, and coping strategies in positive ways.

Many different faiths encourage spirituality, even though they use different names for the process - a Christian monk would not say he had attained Nirvana - but they may be referring to similar phenomena.

The researchers say the selflessness that comes with spirituality enhances characteristics that are important for adopting a global society based on the virtues of peace and cooperation.

Professor Cohen said: 'In many ways, the results of our study support the idea that spirituality functions as a personality trait.

'With increased spirituality people reduce their sense of self and feel a greater sense of oneness and connectedness with the rest of the universe.

'What was interesting was that frequency of participation in religious activities or the perceived degree of congregational support was not found to be significant in the relationships between personality, spirituality, religion and health.

'Health workers may also benefit from learning how to minimise the negative side of a patient's spirituality, which may manifest itself in the tendency to view misfortune as a divine curse.'

Your article is seriously flawed, containing mischaracterizations and errors. Here is one example from your writings: "Across all five faiths, results showed a higher level of spirituality was related to better mental health, particularly lower levels of neuroticism and greater extraversion despite how often the patients participated in religious activities." "Despite how often patients participated?" The journal article is quite clear that "Specifically, more frequent attendance at religious activities was associated with better mental health (p. 134)." "Across all 5 faiths?" Again, from the journal article: "The ability to generalize results of our study to all faith traditions is limited because the majority of participants were Christians from a midwestern setting.In addition, only limited conclusions can be made regarding the relationship among mental health and BMMRS variables for groups with specific medical conditions given the limited number ofparticipants in each group, as well as limited information regarding disorder specific medical variables (e.g., cancer stage, severity of injury, level of disability, etc.)." (P. 136) In the abstract of the actual journal article, the authors state: "Mental health was not correlated with private religious practices (e.g., prayer)." This is consistent with numerous studies showing prayer does not affect the outcome of various medical post-op recoveries. Rather, the positive impact came from community support. "... the psychological distress that is associated with a serious medical diagnosis or chronic disabling injury may not be significantly alleviated by engaging in religious activities (e.g., praying, meditating) (p. 133). You wrote "the perceived degree of congregational support was not found to be significant in the relationships between personality, spirituality, religion and health." This is from the journal article: Specifically, correlations indicate that the BMMRS Positive Spiritual Coping and Positive Congregational Support subscales are significantly associated with better mental health, whereas the BMMRS Negative Spiritual Coping and Negative Congregational Support subscales are significantly associated with worse mental health. Reading the cited article would be useful before writing an entry. References Cohen, D. , Yoon, P.L. & Johnstone, B. (2009). Differentiating the Impact of Spiritual Experiences, Religious Practices, and Congregational Support on the Mental Health of Individuals with Heterogeneous Medical Disorders. International Journal for the Psychology of Religion, vol. 19:121–138.
It totally makes sense eh? Having a FAITH/BELIEF in a higher power or being or God gives you something to hold onto in the darkness, it can give you a feeling of being loved, and a purpose! There are very few religions that want people to be self-involved and alone ;) Those qualities of Spirituality really can be quite helpful in persevering through your struggles. For me personally, growing up in a church and having faith has been a huge help, but there are still times when truly relying on God/higher power is not easy. Plus, I know Christian people that do not even believe in mental illness (especially depression) because they feel that if you were absolutely leaning on Christ for his help and letting him carry your burdens, or if you were completely grateful for what He has given you, you wouldn’t be depressed! Wow eh?! And totes true (right to my face. They didn’t know I suffer from the Black Dog! Ha!) But, at the time that just made the shame/guilt kick in “religious” style (you fellow religious peeps know what I’m talkin’ ‘bout)… it also discourages me from speaking out and helping to end the stigma that can exist, HUGELY, in some religious circles… Perhaps it is my own shame and fear that is making it hard for others to get the “of this world” help that they need because of the negative connotation that is associated with mental illness within some church groups. God (religion, spirituality) can help, but sometimes a real live doctor and real live drugs are needed. Seeing this written down makes me sorta realize that I gots some work to do about being open about my own depression, especially in religious circles AND with co-workers at my Christian school. Then we can all help end the stigma, and most importantly, educate my students! Thanks BDT for all you do!  Carolyn “Be joyful always, pray continually, give thanks in all circumstances, for this is God’s will for you.” ~ I Thessalonians 5:16 “Health is the greatest gift, contentment the greatest wealth, faithfulness the best relationship.” ~Buddha “If you want others to be happy, practice compassion. If you want to be happy, practice compassion.” ~ Dalai Lama